Counterpoint: Nobody Writing About Has Any Idea What They’re Talking About

Many, many articles have been written about the failure of Some of them have been very good. And, to borrow the commander in chief’s favorite phrase, let me be clear: The launch of the health care exchange website was, in some real way, a failure. In its first days, did not do what it was supposed to do. Its design was not intuitive. It was something that was intended to make a process easier. Instead, it made the process hard. This is a simple assertion, a correct assertion, and an assertion many people have made.

The only qualification you need to confidently say that the launch didn’t go well is a pair of eyes and a laptop. To make claims about why this website launch didn’t go well, however, you need expertise in one of two areas: government tech procurement, or launching websites. This has proven to be a problem.

Tens of thousands of words have been written about this subject, but none demonstrate the mismatch of rhetoric and expertise better than these, from pundit, consultant, professional/serial thought leader, and New York University professor Clay Shirky, reiterating a common argument the he’s been making lately:

Narwhal is the code name that was used for the platform that powered Barack Obama’s campaign. It was complex for software of its kind, and worked well. And this is the guy whose team actually built it:

I suppose the problem is that convoluted government IT contracts and botched web development are very, very hard to make interesting as anything but generic black holes of incompetence and malice, which is how they’ve been characterized by critics on the left, like Shirky, and on the right. This has resulted in a remarkable streak of zero-content partisanship, which leaves readers and viewers both more angry and somehow less informed about how the government deploys technology, which, it turns out, is something genuinely worthy of criticism.

But, Jesus:

Whatever the case, this is a punditry failure of an unprecedented scale! Or is it a pundit procurement problem? Eghgh. Partisan web development: Let’s do better next time.

Read more:

Be Sociable, Share!

Leave a Reply